Break ups can be heart wrenching. I remember my first break up. I was 9. His name was Scott-the relationship lasted a total of four hours-and every communication was done through an intermediary-a mutual friend- I went home, went to bed, and woke up crying-next the family cat-tabitha-wondering if she could understand my pain-rooted in a preteen’s sensitive rejection-
All joking aside, break ups seem to resemble each with certain characteristics-fear of commitment, vulnerability or self-centered thoughts of “why me,” or “you didn’t fulfill my expectation.” So, why should we use the evangelical church as a fair game example? We should, because we have unrealistic expectations of church community, others-centered hopes of self actualization/fulfillment, and we simply don’t have a complete view of Christ’s unconditional love.
Uprooting versus replanting: introduction to a healthy church breakup:
I was plain spoiled as a young married adult in the church. We joined a small group of like minded rebels, aspiring to plant a church that sought to love God and love the nations. What we ended up with was a wise lead elder couple, with arms open to love a group of immature young marrieds and young singles. Looking back, I realize now I didn’t know what I had. We immediately held weekly home group meetings, studying bible topics at whim, eating copious meals together, and sharing our youth with one another-good, old fashioned unadulterated, green youth. It was glorious. We spent 8 1/2 years with that beautiful, organic, friendship-over-function gospel community-it wasn’t theologically rich, but it wasn’t heretical either-it was family-and we made time to grow as such.
We never did grow past 175 people-but oh did we “do life together.” We truly did. We shepherded one another. Sure we had conflict-frustration, throw your hands up-what are we doing-we aren’t growing in numbers moments-but we were an outgrowing of Christ’s church-and we had apostolic input-boy did we ever-leaders, lay people, all kinds of believers coming in and out visiting, loving, shepherding us to grow in the love and stature of Christ, and in service to God and one another.
Fast forward to 2014. I was uprooted and planted into an incredibly theologically rich, mission-ally minded church community. My head spun as people, families, believers of all shapes and sizes swirled around me, life went on, my family grew..and grew…and grew…and here I was, longing again and again and again for friendship. I started to grumble and grumble and grumble about the opposite problem! It was no longer about a lack of vision or mission-which seemed to be our issue in the renegade church plant mentioned earlier-but of friendship. It now wasn’t:where are we going? But rather: who am I in the center of this rich vortex of Gospel centered busyness? All the leaders I once felt so connected with at my previous church, I now felt disconnected, confused, alone. I began to isolate in my busy life, work, family, marriage, and then like clock work, I would abase-repeatedly-abased in my feelings, my purpose, my identity-how had I at one time felt so vibrant, alive, valuable in Gospel community-and now the wife of a staff Pastor-felt so alone and isolated-invaluable -besides my day in and day out duties as a full time marketplace employee, wife, and mother-I could not find my way. **
Rewind to the replanting:
When we left our renegade church plant in 2014, tears rolled as we said goodbye to the elder couple who had shepherded us for 9 years. We had married, reared our first child, and fought through the biracial marriage trenches with these people-they had held our hands, and touched our hearts. They didn’t have all the answers-they probably lacked skills and tools to really teach us in certain areas-but they were a steady place for green folks like us-green as baby bananas-but looking back it was never really about what they couldn’t give us as pastors in the way of teaching, or vision/mission leadership-it was a way of being-it was their willingness to be with us-and be believers in the midst of complete hell on earth-it was a steadfast faith-and a constant commitment to stay that made all the difference.
So we said goodbye. We prepared one another for losing each other’s leadership-theirs as spiritual shepherds due to our decision of geography change, and ours impacting the church’s elder team, and as a result the ins and outs of congregational responsibilities. We supported and loved one another for the hard decisions at our doorstep. We prayed and patted each other in friendship, though the sting of insecurity and the questions of tomorrow presided weeks and months leading up to our family’s move.
As we left our beloved church plant behind, we let go of the first community only to embrace the second. We were being “replanted,” in a second church community, while feeling the bitter sweet transition of voluntarily leaving the first.*
This is the part where I pause and see how leaving a church community does not have to be a “break up.”
Let me just break the fourth wall to emphatically say: you do not have to part ways in church community with pain and regret. Reconciliation can be a vehicle for meaningful goodbyes. Yes, the art of understanding within church community can help us to take our eyes of our own unmet expectations, the need for self-fulfillment, in order to have a more complete view of Christ’s unconditional love for us.
So when we sit in our auditoriums, sanctuaries, and living rooms, we can remember that “breaking up is hard to do.” So hard in fact, that we should consider commitment over expectations, others over ourselves, and Christ’s love over our own and others faults and shortcomings. Even now, struggling to find community in the rich Gospel vortex that I currently belong to, I want to push forward, press in, and I want to remember that giving up on Gospel community does damage-because while there is shepherding in the leaving and the healthy church breakups, I would rather be replanted than be violently uprooted.
So, all that being said, my applicable goal is this: I plan to press in and invite one family or couple into my home monthly for the rest of the year. Maybe even weekly. Because if my “New Testament acts model church community” taught me anything, it was that church is a family-and sometimes a marriage-we sometimes go through some bad to get to the good.***
*depression is a real thing. If you know anyone in the church who feels isolated and cannot seem to see the light of day, Be present. Stick around. You don’t have to have the answers. Sometimes depression is clinical (on going and requires medication) and sometimes it’s circumstantial. Just be a human touch, a relational life line-keep inviting, keep spending the time to see that person in a better place emotionally.
**though bitter sweet leaving the first community, the leaving felt supported, lifted, and above all, done out of love and respect-despite the reasons behind the leaving-there was shepherding even in departing-
***I understand that some that read this have had terrible church leaders. Leaders who manipulate and abuse to an extreme. I am sorry. On behalf of the church I am sorry you were abused instead of loved. If Christ can un marginalize the woman at the well, He can help reintegrate the disillusioned evangelicals and exevangelicals alike.